So tonight there was a terrible accident on the high speed rail. In the strictest known facts at this point there was a lightning strike which stopped the D3115 in it’s tracks (no pun intended). For some reason, the D301 managed to smash into the rear end of the D3115 and derailed it. At present there are 1116 confirmed deaths and 89 others sent to the hospitalover 100 injured, sadly I am afraid this number will only increase.
Chinese news has been rather forthcoming with details and photos since this hit the wires and should be commended with it, providing facts and up to date information as it becomes available. Obviously there is a delay, as the primary concern is to save lives first and throw out media stories second.
Sadly this is not the same case for western news sources, who lately are having a love affair with stories attacking China. For example:
China bullet train derailed after ‘lightening’
China bullet train ‘derails’
China bullet train derailed after ‘lightning’
High-speed ‘bullet train’ derails in China causing two carriages to fall from bridge
Just from the titles alone, it’s obvious that there is propaganda within. The questioning ‘quotes’ are used in this matter to infer that this is the “official reason”, but not the real reason. Now we get to dig into the articles and see what’s going on, but first, lets get some basic facts on straight.
The D series is a low speed “bullet” train part of the 和谐号 class. It has an absolute max speed around 250km/h but tends to average around 150~180km/h.
The D3115 travels on is the Wenzhou-Fuzhou Line which was opened in 2009 after 4 years of construction at a cost of $1.85 billion USD. The fastest trains do in fact travel at 250km/h average speed, however this train was only traveling at around 150km/h. The speed of this train is irrelevant, as it was stopped by a lightning strike related power failure.
The D301 starts at Beijing on the newly opened Beijing-Shanghai line and switches over to the Shanghai-Hangzhou line at Hongqiao and then makes a connection to the Wenzhou-Fuzhou line in Hangzhou before proceeding to it’s terminus in Fuzhou.
This accident occurred in Wenzhou, so based on the time table, I am calculating speed between Wenling and Fuding, which works out to approximately 180km/h. Using basic research skills of openly available public sources, I am able to piece together quite a lot… imagine if I had a news staff.
Time to dig into western sources. I am not quoting articles in full as they are linked, I am not going to bother with the facts that are relevant and accurate, as it is not worth the time.
Daily Mall:
The Xinhua new agency did not say what caused the accident.
China has spent billions and plans more massive spending to link the country with a high-speed rail network. Recently, power cuts and other malfunctions have plagued the showcase new high-speed line between Beijing and Shanghai since it opened last month.
Official plans call for China’s bullet train network to expand to 8,000 miles of track this year and 10,000 miles by 2020.
The huge spending connected with the rail expansion also has been blamed for corruption, and Railways Minister Liu Zhijun was dismissed this spring amid an investigation into unspecified corruption allegations.
No details have been released about the allegations against him, but news reports say they include kickbacks, bribes, illegal contracts and sexual liaisons.
The basic facts in the article are correct, apart from Xinhua not stating what caused the accident (they did). The Beijing-Shanghai issues are fact, but irrelevant to this and out of scope. The corruption charges are irrelevant, as it concerned a separate line entirely.
AFP via MSN (both of them):
The accident occurred less than a month after China inaugurated with great fanfare a new flagship $33 billion line from Beijing to Shanghai that halves the rail journey time between the two Chinese cities to five hours.
It was opened on the eve of July 1 celebrations to mark the 90th birthday of China’s Communist Party and authorities touted it as yet another symbol of the country’s growing advancement.
More irrelevancy, not too slanted, but if you read between the lines (and about half of the article ranting about corruption) the intent is clear. Instigate that the entire system is nothing but fanfare, corrupt, expensive and dangerous. They wont say it directly, but it’s the intent and what they want you to get out of it.
In the expanded and updated version, we get some more quotes which make the intention clear:
China National Radio quoted an unnamed Shanghai Railway Bureau official as saying the accident was triggered by a lightning strike.
But a flurry of postings on China’s popular Twitter-like microblogging services said the derailment was actually caused when a second train ploughed into the stationary one from behind.
The reports also said there were sizeable casualties at the scene, without specifying if there were fatalities.
AFP was not immediately available to confirm the blog reports.
Photos posted online appeared to showed one long rail carriage standing vertical, with one end on a concrete bridge and the other resting on the ground at least 10 metres (33 feet) below.
They also showed people being carried away from the scene, although it was not clear whether those victims were injured or dead.
Similar trains are used on the line where the accident occurred, which was operating before the new Beijing-Shanghai link.
Key points being made here are:
“unnamed”, which implies that it’s a lie
The discussion of weibo postings concerning the D301 crash without mention of the fact that Xinhua said it.
Mentioning official sources not confirming fatalities, while immediately undermining it with “photos online”, which is an attempt to separate the two sources in the mind of the reader.
Finally, we have a linking to other trains, implying that the trains are all dangerous. Keep in mind here, that this was a power failure and signaling issue, not a train issue.
Last but not least, AFP via Google which manages to combine all of the issues shown above while mixing in facts that Xinhua has provided.
The propaganda in recent weeks has been overly excessive. There is clearly some animosity present towards China, as there has been for years, and with the drastic economic differences between the US and China at present, it is becoming more obvious that the goal is to somehow diminish the achievements in China so as not to tarnish the “USA #1″ image desired in the US press.


